The Global Search for Education: What do Finland and Puerto Rico Have in Common?
By C. M. Rubin
"Prompted by the Global Search for Education series, a survey was designed and responses were obtained from 53 female and 78 male students at the University of Puerto Rico, Mayagüez campus, with the aim of exploring gender perceptions." -- Hector Rosario and Dan McGee
When gender perceptions and negative stereotypes towards women in mathematics and science are non-existent, the gender gap in performance seems to disappear. That's the lesson to be learned from not just Finland, but also Puerto Rico where females are performing as well as males and better than males in some math and science subjects.
What we in the mainland US could do to improve girls' image of themselves and boys' image of girls would seem to be the next important question. I invited Dr. Hector Rosario and Daniel McGee to share their fascinating research and perspectives on this topic in The Global Search for Education. Hector Rosario is a professor of mathematics at the University of Puerto Rico (Mayagüez) and holds a Ph.D. from Columbia University. He is a co-editor of Mathematics and Its Teaching in the Southern Americas, an anthology of the history of mathematics education in 17 nations in the Americas. Daniel McGee worked 18 years at the UPR-Mayaguez where he directed numerous projects involving developmental mathematics, high school mathematics, pre-service teacher training and materials for Pre-Calculus and Calculus classes. He is currently director of the Kentucky Center for Mathematics.
What is the status of the gender gap in Puerto Rico regarding Math and Science achievement and how does this compare to the U.S.?
The following quote appears in the chapter on Puerto Rico of the recently released anthology Mathematics and Its Teaching in the Southern Americas.
In the United States, the NAEP exam results indicate that males perform better than females in mathematics. This difference, however, is not seen in Puerto Rico where females perform as well as males. In fact, females perform approximately 5 points higher on average in the Geometry and Spatial Sense section. This lack of a gender gap continues to be seen in post-secondary institutions. Based on data from Río Piedras and Mayagüez, approximately 36% of graduates in engineering programs are women and approximately 60% of graduates from other science and mathematics programs are women. While obviously there is still a gap in engineering fields between male and female graduates, it should be noted that this gap is far less than anywhere else in the United States (Rosario et al., 2015).
"The universality of hard-working moms seems to have changed cultural perceptions among college-bound children - particularly among male students who, interestingly enough, seemed to take negative gender perceptions very personally."
-- Hector Rosario and Dan McGee
What do you believe are the primary factors driving this improved gender equality?
There is evidence supporting gender perceptions and negative stereotypes as major contributors to the gender gap in mathematics and science in the United States.
As a similarly large gender gap is not found in Puerto Rico, a good first step is to look at Puerto Rican perceptions of women in science and mathematics.
Prompted by the Global Search for Education series, a survey was designed and responses were obtained from 53 female and 78 male students at the University of Puerto Rico, Mayagüez campus, with the aim of exploring gender perceptions.
When remembering their childhood, boys tended to remember thinking that boys were more intelligent, harder working, and better at math and science than girls, while girls remembered thinking that girls were more intelligent, harder working, and better at math and science than boys.
Perception of elementary school intelligence
Percent of Girls
Percent of Boys
Girls are smarter than boys
53%
35%
They are equally intelligent
45%
21%
Boys are smarter than girls
2%
44%
Perception of elementary school work ethic
Percent of Girls
Percent of Boys
Girls work harder than boys
44%
34%
They work equally hard
40%
30%
Boys work harder than girls
16%
36%
Perception of elementary school math and science ability
Percent of Girls
Percent of Boys
Girls are better than boys
42%
22%
They are equally intelligent
40%
31%
Boys are better than girls
18%
47%
Perhaps the most telling indicator of student gender perceptions related to how they perceive their parents.
Perception of Math and Science Ability
Percent of Girls
Percent of Boys
Mom is better than dad
27%
26%
They are equal
53%
51%
Dad is better than mom
20%
23%
There is clearly no evidence with this population to indicate that fathers are considered more intelligent or more talented in math and science than mothers.
Perception of Intelligence
Percent of Girls
Percent of Boys
Mom is smarter than dad
29%
28%
They are equal
51%
49%
Dad is smarter than mom
20%
23%
However, there is an overwhelming perception that mothers are harder working - a sentiment especially strong in boys.
Perception of Work Ethic
Percent of Girls
Percent of Boys
Mom works harder than dad
65%
80%
They are equal
6%
4%
Dad works harder than mom
29%
16%
So there appear to be neither discouraging gender perceptions nor negative stereotypes among college-bound boys and girls in Puerto Rico. This would certainly support previous research indicating that these are major factors behind the gender gap in the United States. U.S. Information - http://www.greatscienceforgirls.org/files/Why%20So%20Few%20-%20Women%20in%20STEM.pdf
What, if any, specific strategies were used to improve girls' performance in mathematics? Are there any plans to build on this success?
While a difficult strategy to replicate, the universality of hard-working moms seems to have changed cultural perceptions among college-bound children - particularly among male students who, interestingly enough, seemed to take negative gender perceptions very personally. In an open comment section of the survey, boys were very prone to speak almost movingly of women scientists and mathematicians that influenced their lives. Girls, on the other hand, appear to be influenced by strong women in their family that have told them of past injustice and instilled the determination to study the career they wish to follow.
What can the rest of the United States learn from the Puerto Rican example?
When neither men nor women buy into gender perceptions and negative stereotypes towards women in mathematics and science, the gender gap seems to naturally diminish. Hence, it would seem that the US could have a large return if it invests in improving girls' image of themselves and boys' image of girls as mathematically and scientifically capable of climbing equally great heights.
For more information - http://www.amazon.com/Mathematics-Its-Teaching-Southern-Americas/dp/9814590568